Drawing-through maternal subjectivity

Digital or visual media


McCloskey, Paula 2014. Drawing-through maternal subjectivity.
CreatorsMcCloskey, Paula
Description

These drawings were part of my PhD thesis, Art, Maternal and Matrixial Encounters, (2013, University of Sheffield). Ten years before I completed the PhD research I saw the art-practice of French born artist Louise Bourgeois.1 I had come across her work before, but this time it was different. This time something happened. Viewing the work had an effect on me that I had not experienced before. I was drawn to the images and moved by them. I was mesmerised by the sensations that beholding the work was able to ignite in me. I was a newly single mother in my mid-twenties when this happened. I was in the midst of a traumatic time in my trajectory, a time where I felt lonely and lost. Louise Bourgeois' work was something I felt connected to, it made me feel differently about myself and my situation. Over time, I would come to think and refer to this happening as an encounter, it being an event that marked a tipping point in life. This encounter with Louise Bourgeois' oeuvre, this event that catalysed change is the starting point for this research. Maternity is a theme that runs through Bourgeois' oeuvre. Along with some other pieces, I felt a strange connection to these modest, enigmatic drawings. I experienced an intensity, but of what, I was not so sure. It was not a feeling I could name, but it was something that I felt on/in my body, that led me to seek out more of Bourgeois' work, her sculptures, installation, paintings, textiles and so on. The feelings, the intensity, the sensations all worked in a way that was new and exciting. I could not let go of this 'happening'. I wanted to understand it, make sense of it and learn from it. At the time of this early encounter with Bourgeois' oeuvre I was in a distraught post-natal state3, I felt that Bourgeois', art in a complex way that I did not understand, connected to my maternity. The complex connection to my maternity, both in terms of the reference to the maternal in the images and to how they made me feel is an important aspect of how I experienced Bourgeois' practice from the outset. When I first started to contemplate what this experience, this happening, might be, thinking of it as an encounter – an art encounter. At the time I was ignorant of this concept's use in philosophical and psychoanalytic texts that I would later discover and use when I embarked on this research. I started reflecting on my experience as an encounter, because when I discovered the work of Louise Bourgeois it constituted an unexpected event that I would credit with catalysing a turning point in my life. Once I started this research my understanding of encounter changed, as did my understanding of the encounter I experienced with the practice of Louise Bourgeois. Following the encounter with Bourgeois' art I read about, (among other uses of the concept of encounters) art encounters in the work of Simon O'Sullivan4 and maternal encounters in the work of Lisa Baraitser5, which explore ideas and thinking that art encounters and maternal encounters respectively can potentially have a transformative affect/effect on subjectivity. Both of these books, along with others, which will be explored in the main text, informed how I came to think of the term encounter. The point of raising their use and influence at this stage is to alert the reader to the use specifically of the term art-encounter from the outset as stemming from my initial tacit use of the term encounter to think of my experience of the work of Louise Bourgeois, which would later be informed by reading around art and other encounters. I use it then to literally describe this experience, as well as exploring what an art-encounter is in more general terms as I work-through my art-encounter throughout this thesis.
This research is one outcome of a process of contemplation that I engaged in to try and understand and make sense of this art-encounter. My art-encounter is thus not only used to locate the origins of this research; it is also invoked as a heuristic device to explore encounters beyond the scope of my art-encounter experience. This exploration continues to use my art-encounter, in part, as a case-study to consider, in the first instance, art-encounters' possible capacity for subjective transformation. Part of the contemplation of my art-encounter, which will be explored in more detail in different places throughout this thesis, was a consideration of the place of my maternal experience in the naming of the art-encounter with the work of Louise Bourgeois. The investigation into my art-encounter thus involves a teasing out of the place of maternal experience in this encounter; and, once again, using this experience, or the contemplation of this experience as a heuristic device within this research. In the process of deciphering the place of my maternal experience in the conditions and causes of my art-encounter I explore the potential of using traumatic maternal experience as a site of knowledge in and of itself. The process of inquiry into my art-encounter, and exploration of the place of my maternal experience in this encounter works towards revealing some insight into the conditions and characteristics of possible subjectivising encounters.
This short narrative serves to introduce the research and provides some explanation for the two research questions, below, in terms of the issues embedded into the first, and then to the issues explored through the second: How can we understand an art-encounter's capacity for subjective transformation? When the invocation of traumatic maternal experience is explored as site of knowledge in the context of an art-encounter, what new insights might emerge into the conditions and characteristics of potentially subjectivising encounters? In addition to the exploring the work of Louise Bourgeois, other art and writing on the maternal and written personal reflections on maternal and art as encounters, as part of this research I also looked back to other post-art-encounter activity. Sometime in the post-art-encounter with Louise Bourgeois time I started to draw. I drew every day for a year – tiny black-ink scrawly drawings held in a series of small lined notebooks. The compulsion to do this ritualistic daily practice emanated from a desire to work-through some of the difficult senses, feelings, emotions, thoughts I had that were part of, or which I associated with, my maternity which is hinted at in the written reflections above. The drawings were concerned with exploring those parts of my maternity that I could not access in the writing of others or by writing myself or in the art of others – the pain I experienced that I thought was my own. This exhibition of the drawings are accompanied by a written article further exploring the research.

ContributorsUniversity of Sheffield
Keywordsmaternity and art; feminist art practice; Drawing; Drawing process; Louise Bourgeois; Bracha Ettinger
Date2014
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/623409
hdl:10545/623409
Publication process dates
Deposited28 Jan 2019, 18:13
Publication dates2014
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/936yq/drawing-through-maternal-subjectivity

Download files

  • 4
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Fragile Cartographies of Border Fictioning
McCloskey, P. and Vardy, S. 2022. Fragile Cartographies of Border Fictioning. in: Zaman, Q. M. and Hall, G. (ed.) Border Urbanism: Transdisciplinary Perspectives Switzerland Springer.
FAN Mothers in Our Fragile Social Network against Climate Change
McCloskey, Paula, Duffy, Clare, Zvensden, Zoe, Chicago, Jennifer, Hawkes, Jodie, Townley, Anna, Lovett, Leah and Šimić, Lena 2021. FAN Mothers in Our Fragile Social Network against Climate Change. Journal of the Motherhood Initiative.
Myths for a Wetlands Imaginary, HD Film, 9’24’’, 2019
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2020. Myths for a Wetlands Imaginary, HD Film, 9’24’’, 2019.
The non/inhuman within: beyond the biopolitical intrauterine imaginary
McCloskey, Paula 2021. The non/inhuman within: beyond the biopolitical intrauterine imaginary. Studies in Gender and Sexuality. https://doi.org/10.1080/15240657.2021.1961494
Geopower (Spatial Self Organisation Against Injustice in Sheffield)
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2019. Geopower (Spatial Self Organisation Against Injustice in Sheffield).
Screening of the territories of Eile
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2019. Screening of the territories of Eile.
Performing geopower: Eile and border-fictioning
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2020. Performing geopower: Eile and border-fictioning. Scene.
Myths for a wetlands imaginary
McCloskey, Paula 2019. Myths for a wetlands imaginary.
Constituent relations across the city: Three perspectives from practice
McCloskey, Paula, Vardy, Sam, Udall, Julia and Vodicka, Goran 2019. Constituent relations across the city: Three perspectives from practice.
Border fictioning (Eile project)
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2019. Border fictioning (Eile project).
Territories of Eile, film screening
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2019. Territories of Eile, film screening.
The material-discursive border & territorial-apparatuses {the Eile project}
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2020. The material-discursive border & territorial-apparatuses {the Eile project}. Building Material.
; a place of their own
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2010. ; a place of their own.
Art, Maternal and Matrixial Encounters
McCloskey, Paula 2013. Art, Maternal and Matrixial Encounters. Thesis
Eile Project: Art and Spatial Research UK/Irish Border (2016 – ongoing)
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2016. Eile Project: Art and Spatial Research UK/Irish Border (2016 – ongoing).
Fragile cartographies of border fictioning: a place of their own
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2018. Fragile cartographies of border fictioning: a place of their own.
Audiovisual border fictioning (of the body & territory): the Eile project, AV body conference, Huddersfield University.
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2018. Audiovisual border fictioning (of the body & territory): the Eile project, AV body conference, Huddersfield University.
Victoria Lucas lay of the land: landscape and other stories.
McCloskey, Paula 2017. Victoria Lucas lay of the land: landscape and other stories.
Border field/apparatuses.
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2019. Border field/apparatuses.
Emilie Taylor's beating the bounds: a citical essay.
McCloskey, Paula 2018. Emilie Taylor's beating the bounds: a citical essay.
A place of their own
McCloskey, Paula 2018. A place of their own. in: Spirit Duplicator.
In conversation: Mary Kelly speaks to Paula McCloskey.
McCloskey, Paula 2012. In conversation: Mary Kelly speaks to Paula McCloskey. Studies in the Maternal. https://doi.org/10.16995/sim.60
Post-Partum Document and Affect
McCloskey, Paula 2013. Post-Partum Document and Affect. Studies in the Maternal. https://doi.org/10.16995/sim.121
The potentiality of encounters: a response to Lisa Baraitser’s maternal encounters.
McCloskey, Paula 2012. The potentiality of encounters: a response to Lisa Baraitser’s maternal encounters. Studies in Gender and Sexuality. 13 (2), pp. 89-93. https://doi.org/10.1080/15240657.2012.682908
Photograph: Dr Paula McCloskey presenting her lecture art, maternal and matrixial encounters at the Mother Voices midsummer eve's potlach and the launch of the Mother Voices foundation.
McCloskey, Paula 2014. Photograph: Dr Paula McCloskey presenting her lecture art, maternal and matrixial encounters at the Mother Voices midsummer eve's potlach and the launch of the Mother Voices foundation.
Reflections on belongings and becomings; art, maternity and family activism.
McCloskey, Paula 2017. Reflections on belongings and becomings; art, maternity and family activism.
Art and maternal subjectivity: an ongoing relation
McCloskey, Paula 2015. Art and maternal subjectivity: an ongoing relation.
Family activist network performance
McCloskey, Paula 2014. Family activist network performance.
Family Entanglements
McCloskey, Paula and Vardy, Sam 2018. Family Entanglements.
Otherlings
Bartram, Angela, McCloskey, Paula, Baker, Steve, Davies, Huw, Basi, Philip Ranjit, Fisher, Craig, Vardy, Sam, Rushton, S., Mallinson, Mally and Parker, Christine 2019. Otherlings. University of Derby.
Paula McCloskey’ in Loveless, N.S. Contemporary Mamactivist Artists: A Forum on Maternal Activist Art for the Studies in the Maternal Special Issue on The Everyday Maternal Practice: Activist Structures in Creative Work, Summer 2016
McCloskey, Paula 2016. Paula McCloskey’ in Loveless, N.S. Contemporary Mamactivist Artists: A Forum on Maternal Activist Art for the Studies in the Maternal Special Issue on The Everyday Maternal Practice: Activist Structures in Creative Work, Summer 2016. Studies in the Maternal. https://doi.org/10.16995/sim.224
Birth shock: exploring pregnancy, birth and the transition to motherhood using participatory arts.
Hogan, Susan, Baker, Charley, Cornish, Shelagh, McCloskey, Paula and Watts, Lisa 2015. Birth shock: exploring pregnancy, birth and the transition to motherhood using participatory arts. in: Demeter Press.
Experiences and impact of mistreatment and obstetric violence on women during childbearing: a systematic review protocol.
Mcgarry, Julie, Hinsliff-Smith, Kathryn, Watts, Kim, McCloskey, Paula and Evans, Catrin 2017. Experiences and impact of mistreatment and obstetric violence on women during childbearing: a systematic review protocol. JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports.. https://doi.org/10.11124/JBISRIR-2016-002950