The margin of appreciation doctrine and the interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights as a living instrument

PhD Thesis


Ita, Rachael Eguono 2018. The margin of appreciation doctrine and the interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights as a living instrument. PhD Thesis https://doi.org/10.48773/936zx
AuthorsIta, Rachael Eguono
TypePhD Thesis
Abstract

The significance of the margin of appreciation doctrine has been underscored recently with the adoption of Protocol No 15 which calls for the inclusion of the terms ‘margin of appreciation’ and ‘subsidiarity’ in the Preamble of the European Convention on Human Rights. This development reflects the disquiet amongst member States to the Convention that the doctrine is not being given enough weight by the European Court of Human Rights in the determination of cases before it. One of the interpretive tools that is perceived to be having a negative effect on the margin of appreciation is the living instrument doctrine which has been blamed for narrowing the margin of appreciation afforded to States. This thesis brings an original contribution to the literature in this area by considering the interaction between the margin of appreciation and living instrument doctrines in the case law of the Court. The contribution is achieved in two ways: (a) methodologically: through the methodology adopted which is a combination of the quantitative method of descriptive statistics and the qualitative method of doctrinal textual analysis; (b) substantively: through the systematic examination of the case law of the Court from January 1979 to December 2016 in which both the margin of appreciation and living instrument doctrines are present. The lens of the relationship between rights and duties is applied to the case analysis. The case analysis is used to draw conclusions on the nature of the relationship and whether living instrument arguments are superseding the margin of appreciation doctrine where there is conflict. The results of the case analysis also shows distinctions in the interpretive approaches of the Court at the admissibility and compliance stages. The overall results of the study show that there are a variety of ways in which interaction takes place between both doctrines and the nature of both doctrines will continue to require a close interaction between the Court and the State parties in their compliance with obligations under the Convention.

KeywordsMargin of appreciation; Living instrument; International human rights law; International law; Interpretation of treaties; European Court of Human Rights; European Convention on Human Rights
Year2018
PublisherUniversity of Derby
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.48773/936zx
Web address (URL)hdl:10545/623276
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
License
File Access Level
Open
Output statusUnpublished
Publication process dates
Deposited10 Jan 2019, 13:44
Accepted13 Dec 2018
Publication dates2018
ContributorsUniversity of Derby
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/936zx/the-margin-of-appreciation-doctrine-and-the-interpretation-of-the-european-convention-on-human-rights-as-a-living-instrument

Download files


File
license.txt
File access level: Open

license_url
File access level: Open

Rachael Ita Thesis.pdf
License: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
File access level: Open

  • 77
    total views
  • 14
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as