The first rule of judging club…: inside the saltire society literary awards

Journal article


Marsden, Stevie and Squires, Claire 2019. The first rule of judging club…: inside the saltire society literary awards. Journal of Cultural Analysis and Social Change. 4 (2). https://doi.org/10.20897/jcasc/6354
AuthorsMarsden, Stevie and Squires, Claire
Abstract

Book awards are a pervasive aspect of contemporary book culture, attracting both substantial media and scholarly attention. They confer prestige, create marketing opportunities, push sales, and contribute to the early stages of canon formation. Yet, beyond occasional media splashes when judges break ranks and disagree, there is little insight into the administrative and decision-making processes inside book awards. This article draws on the autoethnographic experiences of two academic researchers, who were simultaneously participants (as administrator and judge) for the Saltire Society Literary Awards. In so doing, the article gives insight into particular moments within the administration and judging of the awards, such as changes instigated by research findings and debates surrounding gender imbalance in Scottish literary award culture. It also examines some of the challenges of operating as embedded researchers. The article analyses what autoethnographic methods can bring to an understanding of the Saltire Society’s Literary Awards and other cultural awards, and the implications of embedded research and collaborative autoethnography for 21st century book culture scholarship more widely. It reflects upon modes of embedded research by making evident the challenges and dilemmas of researching from the ‘inside’. The ethical framework for such research is far from simple, but in exploring particular moments with perspectives from both inside and outside the judging processes, and in interrogating the practices of literary consecration, the article casts light upon this particular ‘judging club’ and its practices, and illuminates ways in which researchers might consider, orientate, and carry out further research into processes of cultural consecration.

Keywordsliterary awards, literary prizes, autoethnography, embedded research, Saltire Society, judging, cultural consecration, literary gatekeeping
Year2019
JournalJournal of Cultural Analysis and Social Change
Journal citation4 (2)
PublisherLectito BV
ISSN2589-1316
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.20897/jcasc/6354
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/624848
hdl:10545/624848
Publication dates11 Dec 2019
Publication process dates
Deposited29 May 2020, 14:28
Accepted2019
ContributorsUniversity of Leicester and University of Stirling
File
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/94334/the-first-rule-of-judging-club-inside-the-saltire-society-literary-awards

Download files

  • 21
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Diversity and opportunity in the UK media industries
Marsden, Stevie 2019. Diversity and opportunity in the UK media industries. in:
Twenty-first century book studies: the state of the discipline
Noorda, Rachel and Marsden, Stevie 2019. Twenty-first century book studies: the state of the discipline. Book History. 22 (1), pp. 370-397. https://doi.org/10.1353/bh.2019.0013
Why women don’t win literary awards: the saltire society literary awards and implicit stereotyping
Marsden, Stevie 2019. Why women don’t win literary awards: the saltire society literary awards and implicit stereotyping. Women: A Cultural Review. 30 (1), pp. 43-65. https://doi.org/10.1080/09574042.2018.1561047
‘I didn’t know you could read': questioning the legitimacy of Kim Kardashian-West’s status as a cultural and literary intermediary
Marsden, Stevie 2018. ‘I didn’t know you could read': questioning the legitimacy of Kim Kardashian-West’s status as a cultural and literary intermediary. Logos. 29 (2-3), pp. 64-79. https://doi.org/10.1163/18784712-02902008
‘Eating, sleeping, breathing, reading’: the zoella book club and the young woman reader in the 21st Century
Branagh-Miscampbell, Maxine and Marsden, Stevie 2019. ‘Eating, sleeping, breathing, reading’: the zoella book club and the young woman reader in the 21st Century. Participations: journal of audience and reception studies.