ECEC Discourses in England, Germany, Japan and Korea: Framing the Departure from the Male-Breadwinner Ideology

Conference paper


Lee, S. 2018. ECEC Discourses in England, Germany, Japan and Korea: Framing the Departure from the Male-Breadwinner Ideology. XIX ISA World Conference of Sociology. Toronto, Canada 15 - 21 Jul 2018 XIX ISA World Conference of Sociology.
AuthorsLee, S.
TypeConference paper
Abstract

Childcare and early education (ECEC) policies, along with other 'work-family' measures, have been widely seen to signify a departure from assumptions based on male-breadwinner model families that had underpinned social policy since welfare states’ origins. Against this background of shifting assumptions about what policies for families and children are supposed to achieve, policymakers in many countries have framed ECEC expansion as ‘social investment’. Yet there is large variation in the way that ECEC policies have been expanded and different outcomes in terms of sufficient availability of ECEC, the weight of public and private provision, the adequacy of state subsidies of costs and the educational quality of ECEC institutions. This paper examines this expansion in four countries spanning different welfare regimes in Europe and East Asia, and in which the ideological shifts away from assumptions based on male-breadwinner model families have been particularly stark: England, Germany, Japan and South Korea. Given that this was a period of shifting assumptions about families and family policies, we argue that both the content and the success of social investment discourses were important factors. More specifically, in the two countries whose reforms were less comprehensive, England and Japan, social investment framing was primarily located in one policy area: child development. On the other hand, in the two countries which saw wider reforms, Germany and South Korea, the concept of social investment was considered more broadly, and explicitly included female employment and demographic aims. In the latter two countries, the social investment discourse helped achieve a consensus on raising social expenditure as part of the national agenda, whereas in England and Japan, social investment framing was not able to subsume more pressing policy concerns into a coherent and dominant social investment discourse.

KeywordsChildcare; Policies; ECEC ; welfare
Year2018
ConferenceXIX ISA World Conference of Sociology
JournalXIX ISA World Conference of Sociology
PublisherXIX ISA World Conference of Sociology
Web address (URL)https://isaconf.confex.com/isaconf/wc2018/webprogram/Paper98910.html
Web address (URL) of conference proceedingshttps://isaconf.confex.com/isaconf/wc2018/webprogram/meeting.html
Output statusPublished
Publication dates15 Jul 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited08 Jun 2023
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/9z285/ecec-discourses-in-england-germany-japan-and-korea-framing-the-departure-from-the-male-breadwinner-ideology

  • 8
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

What determines social service workers’ wages: A cross-country analysis using a Luxembourg Income Study
Lee, S. and Yun-Young, K. 2023. What determines social service workers’ wages: A cross-country analysis using a Luxembourg Income Study. Social Policy and Society. pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1474746423000350
Why are childcare costs expensive in the UK?
Lee, S. 2022. Why are childcare costs expensive in the UK? International Social Security Review . (23), pp. 53-62. https://doi.org/10.23063/2022.12.5
Ideas, Coalition Magnets and Policy Change: Comparing variation in early childhood education and care policy expansion across four latecomer countries
Lee, S. and Himmelweit, S. M. 2022. Ideas, Coalition Magnets and Policy Change: Comparing variation in early childhood education and care policy expansion across four latecomer countries. Government and Opposition. https://doi.org/10.1017/gov.2022.35
Towards optimising children's capability and tackling relative child poverty in high-income countries: the cases of Japan, Sweden and the UK since 2000
Lee, S., Takeuchi, H. and Ivarsson, A. 2022. Towards optimising children's capability and tackling relative child poverty in high-income countries: the cases of Japan, Sweden and the UK since 2000. Global Health Action. 15 (1), pp. 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2022.2084230
Work-family policy expansion and the Idea of social investment: the cases of Germany, England, Japan and South Korea
Lee, S. 2021. Work-family policy expansion and the Idea of social investment: the cases of Germany, England, Japan and South Korea. in: Policy Press.
Why the initiative of free childcare failed to be an effective policy implementation of universal childcare in South Korea
Lee, Sung-Hee 2021. Why the initiative of free childcare failed to be an effective policy implementation of universal childcare in South Korea. Journal of Asian Public Policy. https://doi.org/10.1080/17516234.2021.1955644
Social policy discourses around caring society in Europe
Lee, Sung-Hee 2018. Social policy discourses around caring society in Europe. Korean Women's Development Institute.
A comparative study on social service sector workers' working conditions
Lee, Sung-Hee 2020. A comparative study on social service sector workers' working conditions. Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
Beyond the Policy Rhetoric: The Limitations of Gender Mainstreaming in South Korea Relating to Women and Childcare
Lee, S. 2019. Beyond the Policy Rhetoric: The Limitations of Gender Mainstreaming in South Korea Relating to Women and Childcare. Social Policy and Society. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1474746419000484
The policy discourse of social investment and the impact on socialising childcare in South Korea and Taiwan
Lee, S. 2019. The policy discourse of social investment and the impact on socialising childcare in South Korea and Taiwan. 16th EASP Conference. Taiwan 02 - 03 Jul 2019 East Asian Social Policy.
Not too much and not too little: a comparison of free childcare between the UK and South Korea
Lee, S. 2019. Not too much and not too little: a comparison of free childcare between the UK and South Korea. UK Social Policy Association Annual conference 2019. Durham Univeristy 08 - 10 Jul 2019 University of Durham .
Social Care Service Provision in UK
Lee, Sung-Hee 2016. Social Care Service Provision in UK. Chung-Ang University Collaboration Institute.
Family allowances in the UK
Lee, S. 2017. Family allowances in the UK. in: Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
The socio and political conundrum around the policy initiative of free childcare in South Korea
Lee, S. 2018. The socio and political conundrum around the policy initiative of free childcare in South Korea. 15th EASP conference. Bristol, UK 05 - 06 Jul 2018 East Asian Social Policy.
The socialisation of childcare and a missed opportunity through gender politics: the case of South Korea
Lee, S. 2017. The socialisation of childcare and a missed opportunity through gender politics: the case of South Korea. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/sp/jxx001
Gender mainstreaming in South Korea – a critical analysis through discursive institutionalism around the issue of childcare
Lee, S. 2016. Gender mainstreaming in South Korea – a critical analysis through discursive institutionalism around the issue of childcare. LHSS, University of Derby.
Has Childcare Become Less of a Burden in South Korea? Exploring the nature of pre and post reform childcare provision
Lee, S. 2016. Has Childcare Become Less of a Burden in South Korea? Exploring the nature of pre and post reform childcare provision. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.1080/12259276.2016.1242941