Twenty-seven years of controversy: The perils of PGD

Journal article


Cherkassky, L. 2018. Twenty-seven years of controversy: The perils of PGD. International Journal of Pediatrics and Neonatal Health.
AuthorsCherkassky, L.
Abstract

It has been 27 years since the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 was passed in the United Kingdom in response to advances in fertility treatment. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis - the screening of embryos for genetic diseases - has led to lengthy ethical debates on sex selection, eugenics, disabilities, saviour siblings, surplus embryos and most recently, adult-onset diseases (the BRCA cancer gene). This article provides an overview of how the law and practice of PGD in the United Kingdom and United States over the last quarter of a century has developed into new ‘branches’ of PGD, and predicts where they may be heading in the future. It concludes that many of the adverse views on PGD are unfounded and that some of these unique branches may develop to accommodate the screening of additional social traits. An underlying conflict between reproductive autonomy and a right to an open future is also rising under the surface to be noted for the future.

KeywordsEmbryos; Screening; UK law
Year2018
JournalInternational Journal of Pediatrics and Neonatal Health
PublisherBioCore
ISSN25724355
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/622151
hdl:10545/622151
Publication dates17 Jan 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited16 Feb 2018, 16:10
Accepted28 Dec 2017
ContributorsUniversity of Derby
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/94x18/twenty-seven-years-of-controversy-the-perils-of-pgd

Download files

  • 70
    total views
  • 38
    total downloads
  • 10
    views this month
  • 5
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

RE: AB (termination of pregnancy)[2019] EWA CIV 1215: ‘wishes and feelings’ under the mental capacity act 2005
Cherkassky, L. 2020. RE: AB (termination of pregnancy)[2019] EWA CIV 1215: ‘wishes and feelings’ under the mental capacity act 2005. Medical Law Review. https://doi.org/10.1093/medlaw/fwaa009
Do parents have a right to determine where a child patient dies?
Cherkassky, L. 2019. Do parents have a right to determine where a child patient dies? in: Trivent Publishing.
Y v A Healthcare Trust and the Mental Capacity Act 2005: taking gamete retrieval to the bank
Cherkassky, L. 2019. Y v A Healthcare Trust and the Mental Capacity Act 2005: taking gamete retrieval to the bank. Law Quarterly Review.
Human tissue authority new draft code: Supporting child donors or supporting parents?
Cherkassky, L. 2017. Human tissue authority new draft code: Supporting child donors or supporting parents? Legal Issues Journal.
A gift or a waste? Quintavalle, surplus embryos and the Abortion Act 1967.
Cherkassky, L. 2017. A gift or a waste? Quintavalle, surplus embryos and the Abortion Act 1967. The New Bioethics. https://doi.org/10.1080/20502877.2017.1345089
Quintavalle: The quandry in bioethics
Cherkassky, L. 2016. Quintavalle: The quandry in bioethics. Journal of Law and Health.
The interfamilial principle and the harvest festival
Cherkassky, L. 2016. The interfamilial principle and the harvest festival. European Journal of Health Law. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718093-12341379
Selecting a disabled embryo can constitute grievous bodily harm
Cherkassky, L. 2015. Selecting a disabled embryo can constitute grievous bodily harm. Medico-Legal Journal of Ireland.
The wrong harvest: The law on saviour siblings
Cherkassky, L. 2015. The wrong harvest: The law on saviour siblings. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family. https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/ebu014
Gillick, bone marrow and teenagers
Cherkassky, L. 2015. Gillick, bone marrow and teenagers. Medico Legal Journal. https://doi.org/10.1177/0025817215579170
The human tissue authority and saviour siblings
Cherkassky, L. 2015. The human tissue authority and saviour siblings. Journal of Bone Research. https://doi.org/10.4172/2329-8820.1000158
Text, cases and materials on medical law
Cherkassky, L. 2015. Text, cases and materials on medical law. Pearson.
Children and the doctrine of substituted judgement.
Cherkassky, L. 2014. Children and the doctrine of substituted judgement. Medical Law International. https://doi.org/10.1177/0968533215571955
Course notes: Criminal Law
Cherkassky, L. 2012. Course notes: Criminal Law. Routledge.
Does the US do it better? A comparative analysis of liver allocation protocols in the United Kingdom and the United States
Cherkassky, L. 2011. Does the US do it better? A comparative analysis of liver allocation protocols in the United Kingdom and the United States. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.
Legal skills
Cherkassky, L. 2011. Legal skills. Palgrave Macmillan.
The secret world of liver transplant candidate assessment
Cherkassky, L. 2011. The secret world of liver transplant candidate assessment. Medical Law International.
A fair trial? The assessment of liver transplant candidates with psychiatric illnesses
Cherkassky, L. 2011. A fair trial? The assessment of liver transplant candidates with psychiatric illnesses. Journal of Medical Ethics.
Being informed: the complexities of knowledge, deception and consent when transmitting HIV
Cherkassky, L. 2010. Being informed: the complexities of knowledge, deception and consent when transmitting HIV. Journal of Criminal Law.
Presumed consent in organ donation: is the duty finally upon us?
Cherkassky, L. 2010. Presumed consent in organ donation: is the duty finally upon us? European Journal of Health Law.
Rational rejection? the ethical complications of assessing organ transplant candidates in the UK and the USA
Cherkassky, L. 2010. Rational rejection? the ethical complications of assessing organ transplant candidates in the UK and the USA. Journal of Law and Medicine.
The meaning of "wrong" in the M'Naghten test
Cherkassky, L. 2009. The meaning of "wrong" in the M'Naghten test. Criminal Lawyer.
Engaging new Law lecturers and reflections on the engagement
Cherkassky, L., Gale, Christopher and Guth, Jessica 2009. Engaging new Law lecturers and reflections on the engagement. The Law Teacher.
Genocide: punishing a moral wrong
Cherkassky, L. 2009. Genocide: punishing a moral wrong. International Criminal Law Review.
Kennedy and unlawful act manslaughter: an unorthodox application of the doctrine of causation
Cherkassky, L. 2008. Kennedy and unlawful act manslaughter: an unorthodox application of the doctrine of causation. Journal of Criminal Law.
What distinguishes the evil of genocide and how should we respond to it?
Cherkassky, L. 2008. What distinguishes the evil of genocide and how should we respond to it? International Journal of Punishment and Sentencing.
R v Hendy: intoxication and diminished responsibility
Cherkassky, L. 2007. R v Hendy: intoxication and diminished responsibility. Journal of Criminal Law.