Stratified realities: convergence and mediation in non-fiction collage film.

Conference Presentation


Bosward, Marc 2018. Stratified realities: convergence and mediation in non-fiction collage film.
AuthorsBosward, Marc
TypeConference Presentation
Abstract

Positivist thinking has been highly influential on the development of documentary film in the English-speaking world. Brian Winston (1995) argues that this is explained by the perception of the camera as a scientific instrument that provides the facility to deliver an unmediated reality intact to the viewer. This conceit has been central to documentary production in the English speaking cannon, underpinning the truth claims of direct cinema and its observational, objective ethos. In contrast, Documentary filmmakers such as Adam Curtis and Joshua Oppenheimer, working within strategies that openly embrace the synthesis of documentary with experimental and fictional practice, have suggested that the language of non-fiction must develop new tools for adequately addressing the heterogeneity and plurality of the social world. This implies that the complexity of unequal relations determining social forces cannot be adequately described by conventional documentary representation, particularly those conventions tied to tenets of objectivity and balance. The research aims to address this need by developing non-fictional collage as a method for interrogating the mechanisms that shape the social world. The project’s practical methodology emphasises fabrication, simultaneity and layering as tools with the potential to extend the vocabulary of documentary film. The paper will present a body of practice research that explores the intersection of collage, found footage film, animation, documentary and critical realism. The practice investigates digital compositing, hybridity and the capacity for spatial layering to generate an intermediate, unstable aesthetic that cannot be assigned to any singular, unitary ontological level. The paper argues that these conditions provoke an elasticity and ambiguity that dissolves binary distinctions between mimesis and abstraction, reflecting the non-dualist standpoint of critical realism at a medial point between positivist and idealist perspectives. The research deploys the particular constructedness and intermediality of collage as a disruption to ideologically conditioned appearance forms. This posits the practice as a challenge to reductive accounts of the socio-historical world in dominant visual cultures under capitalism. The paper claims that in contrast to unmediated live action images, the hybridity of collage has the potential to more adequately describe the complexity and contingency of reality. The paper explores the layered composite of colliding images as the locus of collage as political discourse. This lies in its facility to surpass the limitations of the monovalent image through the dialectical tension of simultaneity and coexistence. The capacity of collage to describe the interdependence and complexity of socio-historical phenomena is underpinned by the critical realist concept of stratified reality, an idea that advances an ontology comprised of co-dependent structures and mechanisms. The project draws from theoretical debates in experimental and animated documentary that assert the legitimacy of explicit construction and fabrication in non-fictional address. The paper argues that the persistence of collage lies in its continuing relevance as a process of working through and negotiating the complexity of an increasing interconnected and disorientating world.

Positivist thinking has been highly influential on the development of documentary film in the English-speaking world. Brian Winston (1995) argues that this is explained by the perception of the camera as a scientific instrument that provides the facility to deliver an unmediated reality intact to the viewer. This conceit has been central to documentary production in the English speaking cannon, underpinning the truth claims of direct cinema and its observational, objective ethos. In contrast, Documentary filmmakers such as Adam Curtis and Joshua Oppenheimer, working within strategies that openly embrace the synthesis of documentary with experimental and fictional practice, have suggested that the language of non-fiction must develop new tools for adequately addressing the heterogeneity and plurality of the social world. This implies that the complexity of unequal relations determining social forces cannot be adequately described by conventional documentary representation, particularly those conventions tied to tenets of objectivity and balance. The research aims to address this need by developing non-fictional collage as a method for interrogating the mechanisms that shape the social world. The project’s practical methodology emphasises fabrication, simultaneity and layering as tools with the potential to extend the vocabulary of documentary film.

The paper will present a body of practice research that explores the intersection of collage, found footage film, animation, documentary and critical realism. The practice investigates digital compositing, hybridity and the capacity for spatial layering to generate an intermediate, unstable aesthetic that cannot be assigned to any singular, unitary ontological level. The paper argues that these conditions provoke an elasticity and ambiguity that dissolves binary distinctions between mimesis and abstraction, reflecting the non-dualist standpoint of critical realism at a medial point between positivist and idealist perspectives. The research deploys the particular constructedness and intermediality of collage as a disruption to ideologically conditioned appearance forms. This posits the practice as a challenge to reductive accounts of the socio-historical world in dominant visual cultures under capitalism. The paper claims that in contrast to unmediated live action images, the hybridity of collage has the potential to more adequately describe the complexity and contingency of reality. The paper explores the layered composite of colliding images as the locus of collage as political discourse. This lies in its facility to surpass the limitations of the monovalent image through the dialectical tension of simultaneity and coexistence.

The capacity of collage to describe the interdependence and complexity of socio-historical phenomena is underpinned by the critical realist concept of stratified reality, an idea that advances an ontology comprised of co-dependent structures and mechanisms. The project draws from theoretical debates in experimental and animated documentary that assert the legitimacy of explicit construction and fabrication in non-fictional address. The paper argues that the persistence of collage lies in its continuing relevance as a process of working through and negotiating the complexity of an increasing interconnected and disorientating world.

KeywordsDocumentary; Animation; Found Footage; Collage; Critical Realism
Year2018
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/623003
hdl:10545/623003
File
File Access Level
Open
Publication dates07 Sep 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited02 Oct 2018, 10:52
ContributorsUniversity of Derby
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/952vv/stratified-realities-convergence-and-mediation-in-non-fiction-collage-film

Download files


File
license.txt
File access level: Open

  • 23
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

A Deeper Picture: A Realist Semiotics of Non-Fiction Film
Bosward, M. 2023. A Deeper Picture: A Realist Semiotics of Non-Fiction Film . International Association of Critical Realism Conference, Manila .
Archive Film Collage and the Mediation of Marginalised Places
Bosward, M. 2023. Archive Film Collage and the Mediation of Marginalised Places. British Academy: Culture and Heritage in the Digital Age. British Academy.
Picking up the Pieces: Archive Film and the Unseen Past
Bosward, M. 2022. Picking up the Pieces: Archive Film and the Unseen Past . Shadow screens: unmade, unseen, unreleased film and television. Sheffield Hallam University .
Dark Fringes: Complexity and Emergence in Realist Collage
Bosward, Marc 2019. Dark Fringes: Complexity and Emergence in Realist Collage.
Layered Realities and the Narration of History
Bosward, Marc 2020. Layered Realities and the Narration of History. in: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Social Software: Archives, The Digital and Radical Histories
Bosward, Marc 2019. Social Software: Archives, The Digital and Radical Histories.
Wales on Film: Memory, Identity, Politics
Bosward, Marc 2019. Wales on Film: Memory, Identity, Politics.
Caennenau
Bosward, Marc 2019. Caennenau.
Layered Realities and the Narration of History
Marc, Bosward 2019. Layered Realities and the Narration of History. QUAD/ FORMAT.
Layers, traces and gaps: Collage, found footage and the contested past
Bosward, Marc 2017. Layers, traces and gaps: Collage, found footage and the contested past.
Fractured pasts: Found footage collage and the animated documentary
Bosward, Marc 2017. Fractured pasts: Found footage collage and the animated documentary.
Manifest destiny, violence and transcendence
Bosward, Marc 2011. Manifest destiny, violence and transcendence.
Manifest destiny, violence and transcendence – an artist’s statement
Bosward, Marc 2012. Manifest destiny, violence and transcendence – an artist’s statement. in: University of Salford Press.
Illustrated worlds, virtual environments and authorial voice
Bosward, Marc and Levesley, Richard 2013. Illustrated worlds, virtual environments and authorial voice.
Illustrated worlds
Bosward, Marc and Levesley, Richard 2013. Illustrated worlds. VaroomLab Journal.
Designing a new documentary landscape: A renegotiation of documentary voice through animated collage
Bosward, Marc and Bevan, Greg 2013. Designing a new documentary landscape: A renegotiation of documentary voice through animated collage. Scene. https://doi.org/10.1386/scene.1.3.443_1
'Reality fragments' - Found footage, video collage and non-fiction
Bosward, Marc 2015. 'Reality fragments' - Found footage, video collage and non-fiction.
‘The Found Footage Composite: History, Hybridity and the Animated World’
Bosward, Marc 2016. ‘The Found Footage Composite: History, Hybridity and the Animated World’.
A Mixed History: Colliding Realities and the Hybrid Aesthetic
Bosward, Marc 2016. A Mixed History: Colliding Realities and the Hybrid Aesthetic.
Life Goes On
Bosward, Marc 2016. Life Goes On.
Layers of meaning, layers of truth: fragmented histories and composited video collage
Bosward, Marc 2016. Layers of meaning, layers of truth: fragmented histories and composited video collage.
'I Speak about Myself to You' – Renegotiating the Voice of Documentary through Animation Aesthetics
Bosward, Marc and Bevan, Greg 2011. 'I Speak about Myself to You' – Renegotiating the Voice of Documentary through Animation Aesthetics. The Higher Education Academy.
From Pillar to Post (and back again): animation projection mapped onto the basement pillars of Strutt’s North Mill, Belper for a Museums at Night Event.
Shore, Tim, Bosward, Marc, Mellor, Shane and Poynton, Stuart 2014. From Pillar to Post (and back again): animation projection mapped onto the basement pillars of Strutt’s North Mill, Belper for a Museums at Night Event.
Rebirth: a light and sound show. Animation projection mapped onto the windows of Strutt’s North Mill
Shore, Tim, Bosward, Marc and Poynton, Stuart 2014. Rebirth: a light and sound show. Animation projection mapped onto the windows of Strutt’s North Mill.
From pillar to post
Bosward, Marc, Shore, Tim and Poynton, Stuart 2014. From pillar to post.
Forge
Bosward, Marc, Shore, Tim and Poynton, Stuart 2014. Forge.
The shape of my thoughts
Baggaley, Phil, Brown, Michael, Bosward, Marc, Poynton, Stuart and Thorpe, Hayley 2016. The shape of my thoughts.