Reflections on personal development within a Professional Doctorate: what development framework is appropriate?

Conference Presentation


Borrie, A. 2022. Reflections on personal development within a Professional Doctorate: what development framework is appropriate? UKCGE 5th International Conference in Developments in Doctoral Education.
AuthorsBorrie, A.
TypeConference Presentation
Abstract

In my career I have worked concurrently in academia and professional practice in sport. Having completed a professional doctorate I am now engaged in designing and delivering on DProf programmes. My experiences have led me to question whether current academic personal development frameworks are relevant for DProf learners. Current frameworks, such as the Vitae Researcher Development Framework (RDF), focuses almost exclusively on the development of the student as a researcher. However, my experience suggests that many DProf learners are not undertaking their doctoral journey with the aim of becoming researchers. My own DProf experience highlighted the disconnect between personal ambition and the RDF. My DProf goal was aimed at bridging a gap between theory and practice with the aim of impacting widely on practitioners. I knew that to achieve this outcome I needed to be ‘multi-lingual’. I had to be able to speak the language of both practice and research and be able to effectively translate between the two. The ‘Engagement’ domain of the RDF is the one that was ostensibly most relevant to my ambition. However, within it the idea of ‘professional practice’ is not mentioned. The framework makes limited mention of presenting to ‘non-expert audiences’ and using ‘non-academic’ publication outlets but the primary thrust is about researcher engaging with researcher. In contrast, I believe that to be an effective ‘translator’ requires specific skills. You have to learn to listen to the evolution of professional language, to keep adjusting your message to maintain cultural relevance, to simplify ideas without losing coherence or accuracy. None of these ‘skills’ were touched upon in the framework guiding my DProf journey ergo it did not develop me in relation to my ambition. I suggest that academia needs to rethink its personal development frameworks to address the needs of a widening population of doctoral students.

Keywordsprofessional doctorate ; researcher development framework
Year2022
ConferenceUKCGE 5th International Conference in Developments in Doctoral Education
Web address (URL)https://ukcge.ac.uk/events/5th-international-conference-on-developments-in-doctoral-education-training
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Open
Output statusPublished
Publication dates
OnlineApr 2022
Publication process dates
Deposited28 Oct 2022
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/9q687/reflections-on-personal-development-within-a-professional-doctorate-what-development-framework-is-appropriate

Download files

  • 6
    total views
  • 3
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Making Reflective Practice More Meaningful: Saying the "unsayable"
Borrie, A. and Ryall, E. 2023. Making Reflective Practice More Meaningful: Saying the "unsayable". in: Cropley, B., Knowles, Z., Miles, A. and Huntley, E. (ed.) Reflective Practice: Critical Perspectives, Pedagogy, and Applied Case Studies in the Sport & Exercise Sciences London Routledge.
Understanding my autoethnographic process
Borrie, A. 2022. Understanding my autoethnographic process. The International Conference of Autoethnography, 2022. .
Talent development: who do we serve?
Borrie, A. 2022. Talent development: who do we serve? The International Conference of Autoethnography 2022.
Meeting the challenge of introducing L8 thinking in a diverse context: a new approach.
Borrie, A. and Miles,A. 2021. Meeting the challenge of introducing L8 thinking in a diverse context: a new approach. UKCGE 7th International Conference on Professional & Practice-Based Doctorates.
Towards a concept of Performance Literacy
Borrie, A. and Padley,S. 2021. Towards a concept of Performance Literacy. Physical Literacy Cultural Connection Around The World: IPLA Conference.