To use or not to use enough water in Travellers’ sites? What does the new planning framework do about water uses and misconceptions?

Working paper


Tracada, E. 2016. To use or not to use enough water in Travellers’ sites? What does the new planning framework do about water uses and misconceptions?
AuthorsTracada, E.
TypeWorking paper
Abstract

During the last few years the author had the opportunity to work in partnership with international researchers in order to investigate on case law issues often affecting negatively the outcome of planning applications for Gypsy and Traveller sites in the UK and other European countries. These research activities took place during a two-year European funded project with the title Wor(l)ds which Exclude (WE). The author and her team in the UK had carried out visits to various sites; reports and recommendations have been written in relation to the latest developments in the planning framework which also regulates the construction of pitches for Gypsy and Traveller users in its special supplement. Some changes emerged after Law Court hearings and relevant decisions referring to accommodation arrangements for Gypsy and Traveller Communities. Although these arrangements were often established after consultation between local authorities and communities involved, rejections of planning applications were often based upon strong disagreements amongst members of local communities and neighborhoods in proximity of proposed new pitches. According to Gypsy and Traveller culture toilets, showers and kitchens should not be integral parts of their mobile homes and caravans; all these facilities should be grouped mainly in blocks of facilities (or blocks of facility rooms) according to the size of the site. Because of certain local petitions though opposing the size and view of caravans and facilities inside the pitches, the facilities’ blocks do not provide enough space and equipment for water uses and drainage. The researchers had the opportunity to visit some sites providing facilities and accommodation and interviewed the inhabitants of the sites. It was also found that often rejections of extensions to planning applications of previously approved temporary sites for Gypsy and Traveller people, when challenged to the law courts, were hardly successful mainly because of planning inspectors and local residents’ preconceptions on these groups’ unsanitariness (not enough use of water) or, strange enough, because of overflows and waste of water during so-called extremely dirty works, such as recycling processes in pitches. In reality, the European Law Courts often found that rejections occurred because of local communities’ misconception on water uses in services attached to the accommodation pitches. The main question should be what the title of this paper is asking, so that the groups interested could get swift and competent answers. The research findings in the UK were compared with solutions and findings in other partner European countries participating in the WE project and an interactive website was created for ongoing discussions and dissemination of best practice activities and projects.

During the last few years the author had the opportunity to work in partnership with international researchers in order to investigate on case law issues often affecting negatively the outcome of planning applications for Gypsy and Traveller sites in the UK and other European countries. These research activities took place during a two-year European funded project with the title Wor(l)ds which Exclude (WE). The author and her team in the UK had carried out visits to various sites; reports and recommendations have been written in relation to the latest developments in the planning framework which also regulates the construction of pitches for Gypsy and Traveller users in its special supplement. Some changes emerged after Law Court hearings and relevant decisions referring to accommodation arrangements for Gypsy and Traveller Communities. Although these arrangements were often established after consultation between local authorities and communities involved, rejections of planning applications were often based upon strong disagreements amongst members of local communities and neighborhoods in proximity of proposed new pitches. According to Gypsy and Traveller culture toilets, showers and kitchens should not be integral parts of their mobile homes and caravans; all these facilities should be grouped mainly in blocks of facilities (or blocks of facility rooms) according to the size of the site. Because of certain local petitions though opposing the size and view of caravans and facilities inside the pitches, the facilities’ blocks do not provide enough space and equipment for water uses and drainage. The researchers had the opportunity to visit some sites providing facilities and accommodation and interviewed the inhabitants of the sites. It was also found that often rejections of extensions to planning applications of previously approved temporary sites for Gypsy and Traveller people, when challenged to the law courts, were hardly successful mainly because of planning inspectors and local residents’ preconceptions on these groups’ unsanitariness (not enough use of water) or, strange enough, because of overflows and waste of water during so-called extremely dirty works, such as recycling processes in pitches. In reality, the European Law Courts often found that rejections occurred because of local communities’ misconception on water uses in services attached to the accommodation pitches. The main question should be what the title of this paper is asking, so that the groups interested could get swift and competent answers. The research findings in the UK were compared with solutions and findings in other partner European countries participating in the WE project and an interactive website was created for ongoing discussions and dissemination of best practice activities and projects.

KeywordsGypsy and Traveller sites; water and drainage facilities; temporary planning applications; misconceptions on health hazards
Year2016
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/618785
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
hdl:10545/618785
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
Publication datesJul 2016
Publication process dates
Deposited25 Aug 2016, 11:02
ContributorsUniversity of Derby
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/929q7/to-use-or-not-to-use-enough-water-in-travellers-sites-what-does-the-new-planning-framework-do-about-water-uses-and-misconceptions

Download files


File
license.txt
File access level: Open

license_url
File access level: Open

  • 22
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Evaluating design features to support inclusive, self-directed, and active healthy living behaviours
Tracada, E. and Sorensen Allacci, M. 2023. Evaluating design features to support inclusive, self-directed, and active healthy living behaviours. Frontiers in Built Environment . 9 (2023), pp. 1-7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fbuil.2023.1232248
Revitalising Urban Spaces to the Needs of the Aging Population - Biophilic Healing Index Supporting Active Aging in Inclusive Cities
Tracada, E. 2022. Revitalising Urban Spaces to the Needs of the Aging Population - Biophilic Healing Index Supporting Active Aging in Inclusive Cities. Japan The International Academic Forum (IAFOR). pp. 51-62
Shape optimisation of cold roll formed sections considering effects of cold working
Qadir, Sangar, Nguyen, Van Bac, Hajirasouliha, Iman, Ceranic, Boris, Tracada, Eleni and English, Martin 2021. Shape optimisation of cold roll formed sections considering effects of cold working. Thin-Walled Structures. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tws.2021.108576
Nature connectedness, human behaviours, and blue infrastructure: the water effect to people in historical and contemporary masterplanning
Al-Wali, Wafaa and Tracada, E. 2020. Nature connectedness, human behaviours, and blue infrastructure: the water effect to people in historical and contemporary masterplanning. Water Efficiency Network, University of Bath.
Invoking humanism in modernity: architecture and spectacle in fascist Italy
Tracada, E. and Temple, Nicholas 2019. Invoking humanism in modernity: architecture and spectacle in fascist Italy. in: Routledge.
Renaturalising the water courses: dynamic interactions between communities and nature
Tracada, E. and Varone, Francesco 2018. Renaturalising the water courses: dynamic interactions between communities and nature. in: WATEF Network/University of Bath.
Recent experiences of urban ritual performances, inspired by Dimitris Pikionis's walkways in Athens.
Tracada, E. 2018. Recent experiences of urban ritual performances, inspired by Dimitris Pikionis's walkways in Athens.
Spatial and economic smart strategies for the 21st-Century metropolitan city of Naples
Caperna, Antonio, Tracada, E., Minervino, Guglielmo, Alatalo, Elina and Cerreta, Maria 2018. Spatial and economic smart strategies for the 21st-Century metropolitan city of Naples. in: Advances in 21st Century Human Settlements Springer Nature. pp. 665 - 755
Renaturalising the water courses: dynamic interactions between communities and nature
Tracada, E. and Varone, Francesco 2018. Renaturalising the water courses: dynamic interactions between communities and nature.
Water valued in green infrastructure designs and human behaviours: Ecocentric values and their acceptance by human beings.
Tracada, E. and Varone, Francesco 2017. Water valued in green infrastructure designs and human behaviours: Ecocentric values and their acceptance by human beings. UPLanD, Journal of Urban Planning, Landscape & Environmental Design.
Florence: a city immersed in fame, water and gardens
Tracada, E. 2017. Florence: a city immersed in fame, water and gardens. University of Bath.
Living with dementia condition in modern cities. Does urban renewal help vulnerable ageing population today?
Tracada, E. 2017. Living with dementia condition in modern cities. Does urban renewal help vulnerable ageing population today? Network for Comfort and Energy Use in Buildings (NCEUB).
Revitilising urban tissue and communities through biophilic participatory design: Normanton Peartree area, Derby, UK.
Tracada, E. 2017. Revitilising urban tissue and communities through biophilic participatory design: Normanton Peartree area, Derby, UK. Architecture Media Politics Society (AMPS).
Music festivals: how are people encouraged to be mindful in their uses of finite resources and not waste water? Where does water go after use?
Tracada, E., Adeyeye, Kemi and Sephton, Neil 2016. Music festivals: how are people encouraged to be mindful in their uses of finite resources and not waste water? Where does water go after use?
The city of future: biourbanism and constructural law
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2016. The city of future: biourbanism and constructural law.
To use or not to use enough water in Travellers’ sites? What does the new planning framework do about water uses and misconceptions?
Tracada, E. 2016. To use or not to use enough water in Travellers’ sites? What does the new planning framework do about water uses and misconceptions?
Music Festivals: How are people encouraged to be mindful in their uses of finite resources and not waste water? Where does water go after use?
Tracada, E., Adeyeye, Kemi and Sephton, Neil 2016. Music Festivals: How are people encouraged to be mindful in their uses of finite resources and not waste water? Where does water go after use?
The city of the future and the laws of physics: Biourbanism and constructal law
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2016. The city of the future and the laws of physics: Biourbanism and constructal law. University of Bath.
The regeneration of minor historical centres: Neighbourhood Agreement II in San Lorenzo Maggiore (Benevento)
Tracada, E. and Varone, Francesco 2016. The regeneration of minor historical centres: Neighbourhood Agreement II in San Lorenzo Maggiore (Benevento). UPLanD, Journal of Urban Planning, Landscape & Environmental Design.
Biophilic urban developments following dynamic flows of tree-shaped architectures
Tracada, E. 2016. Biophilic urban developments following dynamic flows of tree-shaped architectures. International Journal of Heat and Technology. 34, pp. S161 - S166. https://doi.org/10.18280/ijht.34s121
Biophilic urban developments following dynamic flows of tree-shaped architectures
Tracada, E. 2015. Biophilic urban developments following dynamic flows of tree-shaped architectures. Timeo editore.
Biourbanism: Towards a new epistemology in the architects’ education
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2015. Biourbanism: Towards a new epistemology in the architects’ education.
Saint-Guilhem-le-Désert: ‘Le Bout du monde’, ‘Inferno’ and ‘Purgatorio’ in landscape
Tracada, E. 2015. Saint-Guilhem-le-Désert: ‘Le Bout du monde’, ‘Inferno’ and ‘Purgatorio’ in landscape. in: Éditions de l’Espérou.
Water efficiency-people and communities
Bell, Sarah and Tracada, E. 2015. Water efficiency-people and communities. The WATEF Network, University of Brighton.
Words which exclude
Tracada, E., Spencer, Siobhan and Neary, S. 2014. Words which exclude. iCeGS - International Centre for Guidance Studies, University of Derby.
Thermodynamics of architecture and urban fabric: designing and re-shaping cityscapes by laws of Nature
Tracada, E. 2014. Thermodynamics of architecture and urban fabric: designing and re-shaping cityscapes by laws of Nature. Common Ground Publishing.
The Gypsy and Traveller communities’ housing dispute against the Localism Tenet – Social and Cultural definition of Gypsy and Traveller status and gender issues
Tracada, E., Spencer, Siobhan and Neary, S. 2014. The Gypsy and Traveller communities’ housing dispute against the Localism Tenet – Social and Cultural definition of Gypsy and Traveller status and gender issues. in: CREA & Giovanni Michelucci Foundation.
‘Hidden agenda in the last decade: localism and Housing Acts in UK.
Tracada, E., Spencer, Siobhan and Neary, S. 2014. ‘Hidden agenda in the last decade: localism and Housing Acts in UK.
Project JUST/2011/Frac/AG/2716-"WE: Wor(l)ds which exclude-National Report UK"
Tracada, E., Spencer, Siobhan and Neary, S. 2014. Project JUST/2011/Frac/AG/2716-"WE: Wor(l)ds which exclude-National Report UK".
‘Performing in Corso Palladio’ in DAS 2013-VICENCE
Tracada, E. 2014. ‘Performing in Corso Palladio’ in DAS 2013-VICENCE. in: Éditions de l’Espérou.
Hidden agenda in the last decade Localism and Housing Acts in the UK. Where is the good practice in East and West Midlands case studies?
Tracada, E., Spencer, Siobhan and Neary, S. 2014. Hidden agenda in the last decade Localism and Housing Acts in the UK. Where is the good practice in East and West Midlands case studies? Gypsy Studies.
Harmonious architecture and kinetic linear energy
Tracada, E. 2013. Harmonious architecture and kinetic linear energy. in: montpellier.archi.fr.
The Fractal Urban Coherence in Biourbanism: The Factual Elements of Urban Fabric
Eleni Tracada 2013. The Fractal Urban Coherence in Biourbanism: The Factual Elements of Urban Fabric. The International Journal of Architectonic, Spatial, and Environmental Design. 7 (1), pp. 1-17. https://doi.org/10.18848/2325-1662/cgp/v07i01/38355
AIA CPD Workshop to Edra44 Providence: 'Neuroergonomics and Urban Design'
Tracada, E., Caperna, Antonio and Serafini, Stefano 2013. AIA CPD Workshop to Edra44 Providence: 'Neuroergonomics and Urban Design'.
A new paradigm for deep sustainability: biourbanism
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2013. A new paradigm for deep sustainability: biourbanism.
Presentation in Renewbuild Conference 2013 in Gazi University Ankara
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2013. Presentation in Renewbuild Conference 2013 in Gazi University Ankara.
Biourbanism as neuroergonomics in design
Tracada, E., Caperna, Antonio and Serafini, Stefano 2013. Biourbanism as neuroergonomics in design.
Self build design and construction processes and the future of sustainable design education
Tracada, E. 2012. Self build design and construction processes and the future of sustainable design education. in: Athens Institute for Education and Research (ATINER).
Biourbanism for a healthy city: biophilia and sustainable urban theories and practices
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2012. Biourbanism for a healthy city: biophilia and sustainable urban theories and practices. Proceedings of the International Convention on Innovations in Engineering and Technology for Sustainable Development.
Complexity and biourbanism: thermodynamical architectural and urban models integrated in modern geographic mapping
Tracada, E. and Caperna, Antonio 2012. Complexity and biourbanism: thermodynamical architectural and urban models integrated in modern geographic mapping. Conference Proceedings Theoretical Currents II.
Reformation places and the use of senses in their design: Seclusion spaces and heightened sensory awareness/responsiveness
Tracada, E. 2011. Reformation places and the use of senses in their design: Seclusion spaces and heightened sensory awareness/responsiveness. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences. 5 (10), pp. 355 - 370. https://doi.org/10.18848/1833-1882/CGP/v05i10/51929
From Modernism and under the Fascist flag of Italian Nation to Post-modernist urban sprawl
Tracada, E. 2010. From Modernism and under the Fascist flag of Italian Nation to Post-modernist urban sprawl.
Presentation: From Modernism and under the Fascist flag of Italian Nation to Post-modernist urban sprawl: the emergence and the power of the architectural Schools in Italy
Tracada, E. 2010. Presentation: From Modernism and under the Fascist flag of Italian Nation to Post-modernist urban sprawl: the emergence and the power of the architectural Schools in Italy.
Presentation:Reformation places and the use of senses in their design: seclusion spaces and heightened sensory awareness
Tracada, E. 2010. Presentation:Reformation places and the use of senses in their design: seclusion spaces and heightened sensory awareness.
Design codes and design language
Tracada, E. 2008. Design codes and design language. in: Jeremy Mills Publishing Ltd.