Religion and state in marriage, cohabitation and civil partnership

Book chapter


Weller, Paul 2015. Religion and state in marriage, cohabitation and civil partnership. in: Springer Verlag.
AuthorsWeller, Paul
Abstract

I explore several case studies on the relationship between the state, marriage, cohabitation and civil partnership as points of intersection between religious tradition, personal belief and commitment, familial and social belonging, the conditions of modernity, and the structures and laws of modern bureaucratic states. The first example highlights the plurality of legal traditions that can exist within single polities by referencing the historic example of Greta Green in Scotland where, historically, young people under marriageable age in English law eloped and married under Scots law. The second is the controversy generated in the UK in 2007 when the then Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr. Rowan Williams, explored whether some personal law aspects of the Muslim Shariah might be recognized within English law. Next I outline some of the principal meanings attributed to marriage particularly by Christianity in Europe, and where Christian views are generally contractual, companionate or sacramental. In most societies informed by Christianity, the principal form has been monogamy between a man and a woman. There is sharp debate and controversy around emergent forms for the public recognition of relationships between individuals of homosexual and lesbian sexual orientation. What are often popularly called gay marriages highlight the more general problematics involved in questions how marriage, cohabitation and civil partnership are handled in relation to religion, tradition and modernity. Most social, legal and state systems include elements of more than one model and it is unlikely that any one model will be suitable in all circumstances. At issue are how far the state can and/or should impose unitary legal and social policy frameworks and what exceptions and plural approaches can be accepted and implemented? I argue for the development of an appropriate religious literacy among policy makers and civil servants who deal with the above issues. This is not on the basis that social policy and legal developments should necessarily endorse religious perspectives, but because democratic societies need to be capable of connecting with the perspectives and realities of those who organize their personal and social lives according to such perspectives.

KeywordsCivil partnership; Cohabitation; Marriage; State law
Year2015
PublisherSpringer Verlag
ISBN9789401793759
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-9376-6_173
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/622601
hdl:10545/622601
Publication dates2015
Publication process dates
Deposited16 Apr 2018, 15:30
ContributorsUniversity of Derby
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/94086/religion-and-state-in-marriage-cohabitation-and-civil-partnership

  • 10
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Changing socio-religious realities: Practical negotiation of transitions in the governance of religion or belief, state and society
Weller, Paul 2020. Changing socio-religious realities: Practical negotiation of transitions in the governance of religion or belief, state and society. Studies in Interreligious Dialogue. https://doi.org/10.2143/SID.30.2.3288770
Gülen on dialogue
Sleap, Frances, Shener, Oemer and Weller, Paul 2014. Gülen on dialogue. Centre for Hizmet Studies.
Brexit: A colonial boomerang in a populist world
Weller, Paul 2019. Brexit: A colonial boomerang in a populist world. Social Justice.
Tackling religion or belief-related harassment and hate incidents: a guide for higher education providers
Aune, Kristin, Cheruvallil-Contractor, Sariya, Osmond, Jane, Peacock, Lucy and Weller, Paul 2020. Tackling religion or belief-related harassment and hate incidents: a guide for higher education providers. Coventry University.
Learning from experience, leading to engagement: lessons from belieforama for a Europe of religion and belief diversity
Weller, Paul 2017. Learning from experience, leading to engagement: lessons from belieforama for a Europe of religion and belief diversity. Studies in Interreligious Dialogue. https://doi.org/10.2143/SID.27.2.3269034
Christian-Muslim and Muslim-Christian dialogue initiatives, movements and organisation
Weller, Paul 2017. Christian-Muslim and Muslim-Christian dialogue initiatives, movements and organisation. in: Routledge.
Religion and belief-related hate incidents in higher education: a research and evaluation report
Aune, Kristin, Peacock, Lucy, Cheruvallil-Contractor, Sariya and Weller, Paul 2019. Religion and belief-related hate incidents in higher education: a research and evaluation report. Coventry University.
Critical dialogues: Dialogue and conflict resolution - special issue
Mustafa, Demir, Dunn, Deborah, Keyes, Simon, Ramsbotham, Oliver, Shener, Oemer and Weller, Paul 2019. Critical dialogues: Dialogue and conflict resolution - special issue. Journal of Dialogue Studies.
Muslims in the UK
Weller, Paul and Cheruvallil-Contractor, Sariya 2014. Muslims in the UK. in: Springer.
Religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and wales religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and Wales: interim findings and emergent themes
Weller, Paul and Contractor, Sariya 2012. Religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and wales religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and Wales: interim findings and emergent themes.
Religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and wales religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and Wales: interim findings and emergent themes
Weller, Paul and Contractor, Sariya 2012. Religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and wales religion and belief, discrimination and equality in England and Wales: interim findings and emergent themes.
Controversies as a lens on change
Weller, Paul 2012. Controversies as a lens on change.
The clash of civilisations thesis and religious responses
Weller, Paul 2010. The clash of civilisations thesis and religious responses. European Journal of Economic and Political Studies.
Identity, politics, and the future(s) of religion in the UK: the case of the religion questions in the 2001 decennial census
Weller, Paul 2004. Identity, politics, and the future(s) of religion in the UK: the case of the religion questions in the 2001 decennial census. Journal of Contemporary Religion. https://doi.org/10.1080/1353790032000165096
Religious minorities and freedom of religion or belief in the UK
Weller, Paul 2018. Religious minorities and freedom of religion or belief in the UK. Religion and Human Rights. https://doi.org/10.1163/18710328-13011160
Theological ethics and interreligious relations: A baptist christian perspective
Weller, Paul 2014. Theological ethics and interreligious relations: A baptist christian perspective. Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift/Bern Interreligious Oecumenical Studies.
Classroom challenges for teaching about and addressing anti-semitism in the OSCE region
Weller, Paul and Foster, I 2019. Classroom challenges for teaching about and addressing anti-semitism in the OSCE region. University of Derby.
Leadership and ministry, lay and ordained: Insights from rural multi-church groups
Weller, Paul, Artess, Jane, Sahar, Arif and Neary, S. 2019. Leadership and ministry, lay and ordained: Insights from rural multi-church groups. University of Derby.
Religious organizations and the impact of human rights and equality laws in England and Wales.
Kingsley, Purdam, Cheruvallil-Contractor, Sariya, Ghanea, Nazila and Weller, Paul 2017. Religious organizations and the impact of human rights and equality laws in England and Wales. Politics, Religion and Ideology. https://doi.org/10.1080/21567689.2017.1297235
The Gülen Movement in the United Kingdom.
Weller, Paul 2015. The Gülen Movement in the United Kingdom. in: Peter Lang AG.
How far can we go together? Reflection on and from the development of the multi-faith centre at the University of Derby
Weller, Paul 2015. How far can we go together? Reflection on and from the development of the multi-faith centre at the University of Derby. Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift/Bern Interreligiose Okumenische Studien.
Balancing within three dimensions.
Weller, Paul 2017. Balancing within three dimensions. Studies in Interreligious Dialogue. https://doi.org/10.2143/SID.26.2.3200411
Religious freedom in the Baptistic vision and in Fethullah Gülen: Resources for Muslims and Christians.
Weller, Paul 2017. Religious freedom in the Baptistic vision and in Fethullah Gülen: Resources for Muslims and Christians. in: Blue Dome Press.
Violent extremism: Naming, framing and challenging.
Harris, Emma Jane, Bisset, Victoria and Weller, Paul 2015. Violent extremism: Naming, framing and challenging. Dialogue Society.
The emerging inter-faith context In society and religious education.
Weller, Paul 2016. The emerging inter-faith context In society and religious education. in: Mohr Siebeck.
Islam in Turkey as shaped by the state, its founder and its history: Insight through Baptist eyes and three key Muslim figures.
Weller, Paul 2015. Islam in Turkey as shaped by the state, its founder and its history: Insight through Baptist eyes and three key Muslim figures. in: Baptist World Alliance.
Introduction: How and why should we study dialogue?’
Weller, Paul 2016. Introduction: How and why should we study dialogue?’. in: Dialogue Society.
Dialogue theories II.
Sener, Omer, Sleap, Frances and Weller, Paul Sener, Omer, Sleap, Frances and Weller, Paul (ed.) 2016. Dialogue theories II. Dialogue Society.
The politics of fear: Religion(s), conflict and diplomacy
Weller, Paul 2016. The politics of fear: Religion(s), conflict and diplomacy. University of Derby.
Religion and belief, equality and inequality in UK higher education
Weller, Paul and Hooley, Tristram 2016. Religion and belief, equality and inequality in UK higher education. in: Abingdon, Oxfordshire Routledge.
How religion or belief frame participation and access in UK higher education
Weller, Paul and Hooley, Tristram 2016. How religion or belief frame participation and access in UK higher education. in: Aune, K. and Stevenson, J. (ed.) Religion and Higher Education in Europe and North America Oxfordshire Taylor & Francis.
Surveying the religious and non-religious online
Hooley, Tristram and Weller, Paul 2015. Surveying the religious and non-religious online. in: Cheruvallil-Contractor, S. and Shakkour, S. (ed.) Digital Methodologies in the Sociology of Religion London Bloomsbury.
Learning from experience leading to engagement: for a Europe of religion and belief diversity
Weller, Paul and Cheruvallil-Contractor, Sariya 2012. Learning from experience leading to engagement: for a Europe of religion and belief diversity. CEJI.
Addressing religious discrimination and Islamophobia: Muslims and liberal democracies, the case of the United Kingdom
Weller, Paul 2011. Addressing religious discrimination and Islamophobia: Muslims and liberal democracies, the case of the United Kingdom. Journal of Islamic Studies. https://doi.org/10.1093/jis/etl001
Religion and belief in Higher Education: the experiences of staff and students
Weller, Paul, Hooley, Tristram and Moore, Nicki 2011. Religion and belief in Higher Education: the experiences of staff and students. Equality Challenge Unit.