To agree or disagree? An analysis of CSR ratings firms
Journal article
Authors | Conway, E. |
---|---|
Abstract | With the increasing use of CSR ratings firms' data to guide ethical investing and to derive findings in academic studies, there has been a growth in the number of ratings firms. These firms use differing methodologies and data to derive their ratings. Therefore, it is important to understand whether ratings are commensurable, as decisions made on the basis of the ratings data used may differ. This paper assesses the level of agreement between two ratings firms, Bloomberg and CSR Hub across three main CSR subcategories and an overall score. It uses Lin’s concordance correlation coefficient and intraclass correlation coefficient on continuous ratings, and cross-tabulation and Cohen’s kappa on ranked ratings within a sample of 720 US and EU companies. For both continuous and ranked data, there is most agreement on Employees/Social, Community/Social and Overall categories and weaker agreement on Environmental and Governance categories. Firms in the German DAX are most consistently rated, as are large and medium-sized firms. These findings propose a degree of caution for investors and academics using only one rater as the basis for their decisions/inferences. Accounting practitioners should be aware their CSR disclosures result in differing ratings and should consider which raters their key investors use. This paper is original in the comprehensive range of methods used to analyse two ratings firms across all CSR sub-categories, in samples from both the US and EU. |
Keywords | CSR; Correlation; Coefficients; intraclass; Ratings |
Year | 2019 |
Journal | Social and Environmental Accountability Journal |
Publisher | Taylor & Francis |
ISSN | 0969160X |
21562245 | |
Digital Object Identifier (DOI) | https://doi.org/10.1080/0969160X.2019.1613248 |
Web address (URL) | http://hdl.handle.net/10545/623787 |
hdl:10545/623787 | |
Publication dates | 16 May 2019 |
Publication process dates | |
Deposited | 28 May 2019, 09:49 |
Accepted | May 2019 |
Contributors | University of Derby |
File | |
File | File Access Level Open |
https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/947v2/to-agree-or-disagree-an-analysis-of-csr-ratings-firms
Download files
45
total views78
total downloads0
views this month0
downloads this month