Mothers make art

Digital or visual media


Hogan, Susan 2016. Mothers make art.
CreatorsHogan, Susan
Description

In The Birth Project we are exploring women’s experience of childbirth and the transition to motherhood using the arts and then presenting the research findings in films and exhibitions. Our overarching questions are concerned to explore what role arts engagement might have to play in antenatal and postnatal provision, especially where post-birth trauma is being translated into bodily symptoms. The Birth Project is also interested in exploring to what extent clinically-related birth practices are implicated in iatrogenic outcomes and post-natal distress. Furthermore, we are also concerned to investigate what is distinctive about an arts-based approach in terms of expressing narratives about the transition to motherhood. Two sets of workshops have been run to-date for The Birth Project. A participatory arts group, 'Mothers Make Art', has been facilitated by the artist Lisa Watts. Watts has a distinctive art practice called Live Art, described by Gorman as ‘an art practice that presents the living body to encourage a self-reflective exploration of subjectivity, art and knowledge production’ (2014 p.6). One aspect of this way of working is that is ‘engages with how the audience experiences the performing body’s interaction with objects and materials’ (Watts 2010 p.2). Mothers Make Art, asks questions in two ways: what are the effects of participation in workshops for the makers of the art and then what are the effects on others who experience the art that is produced as viewers. The Mothers Make Art group comprised eight women who live in a city in the north of England. They self-selected to participate in a series of twelve workshops. Some of the women were trained in the arts, some not, but all had an interest in visual arts, and an openness to learn and to make. The brief was to use a participatory framework to enable the women to explore any topics they wished with respect to the birth experience and motherhood. In Mothers Make Art structured techniques were used to enable the participants to explore the nature of meaning making and to construct and deconstruct works (physically and metaphorically). An important method employed was the use of everyday objects, (ornaments, clothing, mothering paraphernalia, toys), to help to create stories. There was also an opportunity to be meditative with everyday objects (cling-film, tin-foil, kitchen paper). Rather than making a representation or literal object referring to their birth or mothering, the women focused on the formal aesthetic qualities of the materials. This way of working explores objects with a focus on their material capabilities, rather than having a predetermined vision of where the art making might lead. This not only provided a self-reflective space, but functioned to give the women the skills and confidence to manipulate materials to be able to create their own original art piece at the end of the series. The art works were varied; one women pegged up her boys clothes from the tiny newborn garments to the larger ones representing fads and crazes. She acknowledged the preciousness of each stage with an acute awareness of the fleeting nature of the experience, a heightened awareness of temporality, with poems and a monologue. Another of the installation pieces explored the maker’s sense of stability, with a series of finely balanced and delicately poised fragile mixed-media pieces, comprising living plant bulbs, glass and plastic containers, wire and wood and other materials. Rachel, a medical consultant, spoke of valuing the time and space to make art work. She said that the work was about seeking equilibrium between the domestic, professional and personal realms of her life, as well as exploring notions of what it is to be a good mother. She invited the group to say what her piece evoked: precariousness, balance, complexity, giving the bulbs space to grow, were a few of the reactions.

In The Birth Project we are exploring women’s experience of childbirth and the transition to motherhood using the arts and then presenting the research findings in films and exhibitions.
Our overarching questions are concerned to explore what role arts engagement might have to play in antenatal and postnatal provision, especially where post-birth trauma is being translated into bodily symptoms. The Birth Project is also interested in exploring to what extent clinically-related birth practices are implicated in iatrogenic outcomes and post-natal distress. Furthermore, we are also concerned to investigate what is distinctive about an arts-based approach in terms of expressing narratives about the transition to motherhood.
Two sets of workshops have been run to-date for The Birth Project. A participatory arts group, 'Mothers Make Art', has been facilitated by the artist Lisa Watts. Watts has a distinctive art practice called Live Art, described by Gorman as ‘an art practice that presents the living body to encourage a self-reflective exploration of subjectivity, art and knowledge production’ (2014 p.6). One aspect of this way of working is that is ‘engages with how the audience experiences the performing body’s interaction with objects and materials’ (Watts 2010 p.2).
Mothers Make Art, asks questions in two ways: what are the effects of participation in workshops for the makers of the art and then what are the effects on others who experience the art that is produced as viewers. The Mothers Make Art group comprised eight women who live in a city in the north of England. They self-selected to participate in a series of twelve workshops. Some of the women were trained in the arts, some not, but all had an interest in visual arts, and an openness to learn and to make. The brief was to use a participatory framework to enable the women to explore any topics they wished with respect to the birth experience and motherhood.
In Mothers Make Art structured techniques were used to enable the participants to explore the nature of meaning making and to construct and deconstruct works (physically and metaphorically). An important method employed was the use of everyday objects, (ornaments, clothing, mothering paraphernalia, toys), to help to create stories. There was also an opportunity to be meditative with everyday objects (cling-film, tin-foil, kitchen paper). Rather than making a representation or literal object referring to their birth or mothering, the women focused on the formal aesthetic qualities of the materials. This way of working explores objects with a focus on their material capabilities, rather than having a predetermined vision of where the art making might lead. This not only provided a self-reflective space, but functioned to give the women the skills and confidence to manipulate materials to be able to create their own original art piece at the end of the series. The art works were varied; one women pegged up her boys clothes from the tiny newborn garments to the larger ones representing fads and crazes. She acknowledged the preciousness of each stage with an acute awareness of the fleeting nature of the experience, a heightened awareness of temporality, with poems and a monologue.
Another of the installation pieces explored the maker’s sense of stability, with a series of finely balanced and delicately poised fragile mixed-media pieces, comprising living plant bulbs, glass and plastic containers, wire and wood and other materials. Rachel, a medical consultant, spoke of valuing the time and space to make art work. She said that the work was about seeking equilibrium between the domestic, professional and personal realms of her life, as well as exploring notions of what it is to be a good mother. She invited the group to say what her piece evoked: precariousness, balance, complexity, giving the bulbs space to grow, were a few of the reactions.

ContributorsUniversity of Derby
KeywordsBirth; Art; Participatory arts; Motherhood
Date2016
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/621386
hdl:10545/621386
Publication process dates
Deposited15 Feb 2017, 13:42
Publication dates27 Oct 2016
File
File Access Level
Open
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/94xq4/mothers-make-art

Download files

  • 45
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Effectiveness of creative arts therapy for adult patients with cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Abu-Odah, H., Sheffield, D., Hogan, S., Yorke, J. and Molasiotis, A. 2024. Effectiveness of creative arts therapy for adult patients with cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Supportive care in cancer. 32 (430), pp. 1-21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00520-024-08582-4
Digital arts – refugee engagement
Aljouni, A., Bademci, O., Hogan, S., Marino, S., McDougall, J., Rega, I., Skyrme, S. and Uddin, N. 2023. Digital arts – refugee engagement. Media Practice and Education . pp. 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/25741136.2023.2177953
Short communication: Birth Shock!
Hogan, S. 2023. Short communication: Birth Shock! Elseveir. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.puhip.2023.100371
Birth Shock! Arts In the Perinatal Period
Hogan, S. 2023. Birth Shock! Arts In the Perinatal Period. Derby University of Derby. https://doi.org/10.48773/9ww40
What are the Affordances of Arts-Based Workshops with Refugee Women and Girls?
Skyrme, S. and Hogan, S. 2023. What are the Affordances of Arts-Based Workshops with Refugee Women and Girls? Creative Arts in Education and Therapy Eastern & Western Perspectives. 8 (2), pp. 173-184. https://doi.org/10.15212/CAET/2022/8/12
Photography - Arts for Health
Hogan, S. Photography - Arts for Health. Bingley, West Yorkshire, UK Emerald Publishing Limited.
Intersectionality and Intersectional Analysis in the Arts Therapies: How Does It Enhance Our Thinking about Social Justice?
Hogan, S. 2022. Intersectionality and Intersectional Analysis in the Arts Therapies: How Does It Enhance Our Thinking about Social Justice? Creative Arts in Education and Therapy Eastern & Western Perspectives. 8 (1), pp. 1-10. https://doi.org/10.15212/CAET/2022/8/9
Florence Nightingale, the Colossus: Was She a Feminist?
Hogan, Susan 2022. Florence Nightingale, the Colossus: Was She a Feminist? Journal of international women's studies. 23 (1), pp. 1-15.
Gender-based refugee experiences: the role of education, training and arts-based interventions for girls and women refugees
Skyrme, Sarah and Hogan, Susan 2021. Gender-based refugee experiences: the role of education, training and arts-based interventions for girls and women refugees. University of Derby.
Arts-based Participatory Research in the Perinatal Period: Creativity, Representation, Identity, and Methods
Hogan, Susan 2021. Arts-based Participatory Research in the Perinatal Period: Creativity, Representation, Identity, and Methods. in: Routledge.
Arts & Health
Hogan, Susan 2021. Arts & Health. in: Palgrave Encyclopedia of the Health Humanities Palgrave.
Arts, creativity and health
Bungay, H., Chatterjee, H. and Hogan, Susan 2021. Arts, creativity and health. Public Health. 200, pp. 47-48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2021.09.017
Florence Nightingale (1820–1910) – what does history say about her feminism?
Hogan, Susan 2020. Florence Nightingale (1820–1910) – what does history say about her feminism? Journal of Gender Studies. https://doi.org/10.1080/09589236.2020.1845627
Arts in health: Pregnancy, birth & new parenthood
Hogan, Susan 2020. Arts in health: Pregnancy, birth & new parenthood. in: Routledge.
Photography
Hogan, Susan 2020. Photography. in: Routledge.
Birth shock! What role might arts engagement have to play in antenatal and postnatal care?
Hogan, Susan 2020. Birth shock! What role might arts engagement have to play in antenatal and postnatal care? Journal of Applied Arts and Health. https://doi.org/10.1386/jaah_00013_1
Inscribed on the body: gender and difference in the arts therapies
Hogan, Susan 2019. Inscribed on the body: gender and difference in the arts therapies. in: Routledge.
Unnatural women: reflections on discourses on child murder and selective mortal neglect
Hogan, Susan 2020. Unnatural women: reflections on discourses on child murder and selective mortal neglect. in: Demeter Press.
Arts therapies and gender issues
Hogan, Susan 2019. Arts therapies and gender issues. in: Routledge.
Birth shock!
Hogan, Susan 2019. Birth shock! in: Routledge.
Creative ageing: the social policy challenge.
Hogan, Susan and Bradfield, E. 2018. Creative ageing: the social policy challenge. in: Routledge.
Birth shock: exploring pregnancy, birth and the transition to motherhood using participatory arts.
Hogan, Susan, Baker, Charley, Cornish, Shelagh, McCloskey, Paula and Watts, Lisa 2015. Birth shock: exploring pregnancy, birth and the transition to motherhood using participatory arts. in: Demeter Press.
Gender representation, power and identity in mental health and art therapy.
Hogan, Susan 2018. Gender representation, power and identity in mental health and art therapy. in: Routledge.
Community-based Arts and health in Britain
Hogan, Susan 1907. Community-based Arts and health in Britain. in: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Working across disciplines: Using visual methods in participatory frameworks
Hogan, Susan 2017. Working across disciplines: Using visual methods in participatory frameworks. in: Berghahn Books.
Birth professionals make art. Using participatory arts to think about being a birthing professional
Hogan, Susan 2016. Birth professionals make art. Using participatory arts to think about being a birthing professional.
Art elicitation. Exploring the birth experience
Hogan, Susan 2016. Art elicitation. Exploring the birth experience.
The Birth Project: Using the Arts to explore birth. Interim report
Hogan, Susan 2016. The Birth Project: Using the Arts to explore birth. Interim report. University of Derby.
The tyranny of expectations of post-natal delight: gendered happiness
Hogan, Susan 2016. The tyranny of expectations of post-natal delight: gendered happiness. Journal of Gender Studies. https://doi.org/10.1080/09589236.2016.1223617
“Age is just a number, init?”: Interrogating perceptions of age and women within social gerontology
Hogan, Susan 2016. “Age is just a number, init?”: Interrogating perceptions of age and women within social gerontology. Women's Studies. https://doi.org/10.1080/00497878.2015.1040548
Art therapy theories: A critical introduction
Hogan, Susan 2015. Art therapy theories: A critical introduction. Routledge.
Arts, health & wellbeing: reflections on a national seminar series and building a UK research network
Stickley, Theo, Parr, Hester, Atkinson, Sarah, Daykin, Norma, Clift, Stephen, De Nora, Tia, Hacking, Sue, Camic, Paul M, Joss, Tim, White, Mike and Hogan, Susan 2016. Arts, health & wellbeing: reflections on a national seminar series and building a UK research network. Arts & Health. https://doi.org/10.1080/17533015.2016.1166142
The introductory guide to art therapy
Hogan, Susan and Coulter, A. 2014. The introductory guide to art therapy. Routledge.
Interrogating women’s experience of ageing: reinforcing or challenging clichés?
Hogan, Susan 2015. Interrogating women’s experience of ageing: reinforcing or challenging clichés? The International Journal of the Art in Society: Annual Review.
Mothers make art: using participatory art to explore the transition to motherhood
Hogan, Susan 2015. Mothers make art: using participatory art to explore the transition to motherhood. Journal of Applied Arts and Health. https://doi.org/10.1386/jaah.6.1.23_1
Lost in translation? Inter-cultural exchange in art therapy
Hogan, Susan 2015. Lost in translation? Inter-cultural exchange in art therapy. in: Charles C. Thomas Publishers.
Unpacking gender in art therapy: The elephant at the art therapy easel
Hogan, Susan and Cornish, Shelagh 2014. Unpacking gender in art therapy: The elephant at the art therapy easel. International Journal of Art Therapy. https://doi.org/10.1080/17454832.2014.961494
Your body is a battleground: Art therapy with women
Hogan, Susan 2013. Your body is a battleground: Art therapy with women. The Arts in Psychotherapy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2013.05.003
Peripheries and borders: Pushing the boundaries of visual research
Hogan, Susan 2013. Peripheries and borders: Pushing the boundaries of visual research. International Journal of Art Therapy. https://doi.org/10.1080/17454832.2013.797480
Women’s inequality: a global problem explored in participatory arts.
Hogan, Susan and Warren, Lorna 2013. Women’s inequality: a global problem explored in participatory arts. Special Issue UNESCO Observatory.