Addressing unrealistic optimism with counterfactual reasoning in an employability module in higher education

Journal article


Hanson, Jill and Burke, Ciaran 2020. Addressing unrealistic optimism with counterfactual reasoning in an employability module in higher education. Journal of Applied Research in higher Education. ahead-of-print (ahead-of-print). https://doi.org/10.1108/jarhe-02-2019-0047
AuthorsHanson, Jill and Burke, Ciaran
Abstract

The study aimed to explore the effect of second year business students engaging in counterfactual reasoning on their unrealistic optimism regarding attainment on an employability module. Using an experimental design, the study compared the module performance of those who generated reasons why they would and would not achieve a series of specific grades. A control group who did not generate any reasons also took part. Students who generated reasons why they would not achieve a good grade were less likely to be unrealistically optimistic and more likely to attain a good grade on their assessment. This is a small sample of students from one form of programme, so replication with a greater sample drawn from other programmes would increase reliability. The results suggest an easily applied and practical way of engaging students in employability modules to support their development of a range of capitals.
The findings are considered in relation to the theory of possible selves, the value for students, particularly widening participation of students, of improved engagement with employability modules and the possibility of applying this technique in wider educational settings. This paper extends Hoch’s (1985) original study by considering the use of counterfactual reasoning for assessment performance and offering a an easy-to-apply tool for module leaders to support student attainment in employability development modules

KeywordsEducation; Employability; Counterfactual reasoning; Unrealistic optimism
Year2020
JournalJournal of Applied Research in higher Education
Journal citationahead-of-print (ahead-of-print)
PublisherEmerald
ISSN2050-7003
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1108/jarhe-02-2019-0047
Web address (URL)http://hdl.handle.net/10545/625142
https://www.emerald.com/insight/site-policies
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0/
hdl:10545/625142
Publication dates01 Sep 2020
Publication process dates
Deposited01 Sep 2020, 11:29
Accepted27 Jul 2020
Rights

Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International

ContributorsUniverity of West England and University of Derby
File
File Access Level
Open
File
File Access Level
Open
File
Permalink -

https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/93187/addressing-unrealistic-optimism-with-counterfactual-reasoning-in-an-employability-module-in-higher-education

Download files

  • 351
    total views
  • 20
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Using community interaction theory to understand the effects of group mentoring on adolescents
Hanson, J., Blake, H. and Clark, L. 2024. Using community interaction theory to understand the effects of group mentoring on adolescents. Widening Participation and Lifelong Learning. 24 (1), pp. 36-62. https://doi.org/10.5456/WPLL.26.1.34
Exploring students’ and graduates’ attitudes to the process of transition to the labour market
Hooley, T., Hanson, J. and Clark, L. 2022. Exploring students’ and graduates’ attitudes to the process of transition to the labour market. Industry and Higher Education. pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1177/09504222221111298
SCiP Alliance Thriving Lives Toolkit Enhancement Project
Blake, H., Hanson, J., Neary, S. and Alexander, R 2022. SCiP Alliance Thriving Lives Toolkit Enhancement Project. Derby University of Derby.
SCiP Alliance Thriving Lives Toolkit: Implementation and Impact Evaluation
Hanson, J., Blake, H. and Neary, S. 2022. SCiP Alliance Thriving Lives Toolkit: Implementation and Impact Evaluation. Derby iCeGS - International Centre for Guidance Studies, University of Derby.
Increasing students’ career readiness through career guidance: measuring the impact with a validated measure
Dodd, Vanessa, Hanson, Jill and Hooley, Tristram 2021. Increasing students’ career readiness through career guidance: measuring the impact with a validated measure. Informa UK Limited. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069885.2021.1937515
The importance of an inclusive alumni network for ensuring effective transitions into employment and future destinations for people with learning disabilities
Blake, Hannah, Hanson, Jill and Clark, Lewis 2021. The importance of an inclusive alumni network for ensuring effective transitions into employment and future destinations for people with learning disabilities. British Journal of Learning Disabilities. 49 (4). https://doi.org/10.1111/bld.12429
An evaluation of the North East of England pilot of the Gatsby Benchmarks of good career guidance
Hanson, Jill, Moore, Nicki, Neary, S. and Clark, Lewis 2021. An evaluation of the North East of England pilot of the Gatsby Benchmarks of good career guidance. University of Derby.
Personal Guidance Fund Evaluation: Final Report
Hanson, Jill, Neary, S. and Blake, Hannah 2021. Personal Guidance Fund Evaluation: Final Report. The Careers & Enterprise Company.
International Centre for Guidance Studies (iCeGS) Annual Review 2021
Neary, S., Moore, Nicki, Blake, Hannah, Hanson, Jill and Staunton, Tom 2021. International Centre for Guidance Studies (iCeGS) Annual Review 2021. University of Derby.
Careers coaching for social justice: the case of school leadership and inclusive education for children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities
Robinson, Deborah, Codina, Geraldene, Jill, Hanson and Eleni, Dimitrellou 2020. Careers coaching for social justice: the case of school leadership and inclusive education for children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities. University of Derby.
Developing more inclusive schools for pupils with special educational needs: key messages for school leaders and communities
Robinson, Deborah, Hanson, Jill, Codina, Geraldene, Dimitrellou, Eleni and Qureshi, Sarwat 2020. Developing more inclusive schools for pupils with special educational needs: key messages for school leaders and communities.
Book review: Research methods for ssocial justice and equity in education
Hanson, Jill 2020. Book review: Research methods for ssocial justice and equity in education. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069885.2020.1765229
Future frontiers: the impact of career coaching on year 11 students
Hanson, Jill and Clark, Lewis 2020. Future frontiers: the impact of career coaching on year 11 students. IAEVG.
An evaluation of the Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire collaborative outreach programme
Hanson, Jill and Clark, Lewis 2019. An evaluation of the Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire collaborative outreach programme. University of Derby.
The Gatsby benchmarks and social mobility: impacts to date
Hanson, Jill and Neary, S. 2020. The Gatsby benchmarks and social mobility: impacts to date. IAEVG.
The personal guidance fund- developing new and innovative practice
Neary, S. and Hanson, Jill 2020. The personal guidance fund- developing new and innovative practice. Careers Matters.
International Centre for Guidance Studies (iCeGS) Annual Review (2020)
Neary, S., Hanson, Jill, Moore, Nicki, Staunton, Tom, Clark, Lewis and Blake, Hannah 2020. International Centre for Guidance Studies (iCeGS) Annual Review (2020). University of Derby.
Future Frontiers: The impact of career coaching on career readiness and indicators of successful transitions in Year 11 pupils.
Hanson, Jill and Clark, Lewis 2019. Future Frontiers: The impact of career coaching on career readiness and indicators of successful transitions in Year 11 pupils. Future Frontiers.
Gatsby careers benchmark north east implementation pilot: interim evaluation (2015-2017)
Hanson, Jill, Vigurs, Katy, Moore, Nicki, Everitt, Julia and Clark, Lewis 2019. Gatsby careers benchmark north east implementation pilot: interim evaluation (2015-2017).
Supporting service children in school: An organisational improvement framework
Burke, Ciaran, Neary, S., Hanson, Jill, Parker, Gordon, Everitt, Julia and Clark, Lewis 2019. Supporting service children in school: An organisational improvement framework. University of Derby.
International centre for guidance studies (iCeGS) annual review 2019
Neary, S., Clark, Lewis, Hanson, Jill, Nicki, Moore and Tom, Staunton 2019. International centre for guidance studies (iCeGS) annual review 2019.
Decent work in the UK: Context, conceptualization, and assessment
Dodd, Vanessa Nichole, Hooley, Tristram and Burke, Ciaran 2019. Decent work in the UK: Context, conceptualization, and assessment. Journal of Vocational Behaviour. 112, pp. 270-281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2019.04.002
University Applicant Study: NEMCON.
Hanson, Jill 2017. University Applicant Study: NEMCON. University of Derby.
An evaluation of the Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire Collaborative Outreach Programme: interim evaluation.
Hanson, Jill 2018. An evaluation of the Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire Collaborative Outreach Programme: interim evaluation. University of Derby.
Give yourself the edge: Evaluation report.
Dodd, Vanessa and Hanson, Jill 2018. Give yourself the edge: Evaluation report. University of Derby.
My future: Developing career education and guidance at school.
Moore, Nicki and Hanson, Jill 2018. My future: Developing career education and guidance at school. University of Derby.
Culture, capitals and graduate futures: Degrees of class.
Burke, Ciaran 2016. Culture, capitals and graduate futures: Degrees of class. Routledge.
Capturing habitus: theory, method and reflexivity.
Costa, Cristina, Burke, Ciaran and Murphy, Mark 2018. Capturing habitus: theory, method and reflexivity. International Journal of Research & Method in Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/1743727X.2017.1420771
A new career in higher education careers work.
Neary, S. and Hanson, Jill 2018. A new career in higher education careers work. in: Burke, C. and Christie, F. (ed.) Graduate Careers in Context Research, Policy and Practice Abingdon, Oxfordshire Routledge.
Key skills and training needs of the D2N2 low carbon and environmental goods and services (LCEGS) sector
Paterson, Fred, Baranova, Polina, Neary, S., Hanson, Jill, Clarke, Lewis, Wond, Tracey, Lee, Amanda, Gill, J., Gallotta, Bruno, Eisen, Matthew and Nesterova, Iana 2018. Key skills and training needs of the D2N2 low carbon and environmental goods and services (LCEGS) sector. University of Derby.
Evaluation of Careers Yorkshire and the Humber Inspiration activity and good practice guide
Artess, Jane and Hanson, Jill 2017. Evaluation of Careers Yorkshire and the Humber Inspiration activity and good practice guide.
Business games and enterprise competitions. What works?
Hanson, Jill, Hooley, Tristram and Cox, Annette 2017. Business games and enterprise competitions. What works? Careers and Enterprise Company.
Business games and enterprise competitions. What works?
Hanson, Jill, Cox, Annette and Hooley, Tristram 2017. Business games and enterprise competitions. What works? The Careers & Enterprise Company.
A career in career - understanding what career looks like in the career development sector
Neary, S., Hanson, Jill and Cotterill, Vicky 2017. A career in career - understanding what career looks like in the career development sector. Career Matters.
Transition programmes for young adults with SEND. What works?
Hanson, Jill, Codina, Geraldene and Neary, S. 2017. Transition programmes for young adults with SEND. What works? Careers and Enterprise Company.